Two coats, two different jobs
The Woman Oversized Mac Coat in dark navy and the Woman Cambridge Coat in dark grey Harris Tweed both work as winter outer layers, but they solve different problems. The mac is water-resistant waxed cotton with a relaxed, belted shape; the Cambridge is a below-the-knee wool Harris Tweed coat with raglan sleeves. Choosing between them comes down to weather, silhouette and how you want the coat to feel on.
This comparison sticks to what the catalog confirms. Where a detail is not listed, treat it as an open question to check before ordering rather than a strike against either coat.
What each coat is made of
- WOMAN OVERSIZED MAC COAT - DARK NAVY: Crafted in water-resistant waxed cotton with a contrast button-down front and complementary pockets. Waxed cotton is the mac's defining feature: it points to wet-weather wear and a more utilitarian finish than a wool coat.

WOMAN OVERSIZED MAC COAT - DARK NAVY - WOMAN CAMBRIDGE COAT - DARK GREY HARRIS TWEED: Crafted in classic Harris Tweed in a dark charcoal grey wool. Harris Tweed gives the Cambridge a textured, heritage look and a warmer, more traditional feel than waxed cotton.

WOMAN CAMBRIDGE COAT - DARK GREY HARRIS TWEED
Dark navy mac vs dark grey tweed at a glance
Both are women's coats in the COATS category, but their listed features diverge on the points that matter most in winter.
- Fabric and weather: The mac is water-resistant waxed cotton; the Cambridge is Harris Tweed wool. The catalog does not state a water-resistance rating for the tweed coat.
- Length and shape: The Cambridge falls below the knee with raglan sleeves for an enveloping shape. The mac is described as oversized with a tie belt and customisable back vent; its exact length is not stated in the supplied details.
- Closure and details: The mac has a contrast button-down front and complementary pockets. The Cambridge's closure and pocket details are not confirmed in the supplied information.
- Sizes listed: The mac is listed in S and M. The Cambridge is listed in XS, S and M.
- Catalog price: Mac: USD 465.00 (comparison price USD 750.00). Cambridge: USD 514.80 (comparison price USD 780.00).
When the dark navy mac coat makes more sense
Choose the Woman Oversized Mac Coat if you want a layer that handles damp days and looks sharper than a parka. The water-resistant waxed cotton is the practical argument, and the contrast buttons and pockets give it a polished, Mackintosh-inspired finish.
The tie belt is the fit lever. Because the coat is cut oversized, cinching the belt changes the silhouette from loose and roomy to more defined, and the customisable back vent lets you adjust how the coat sits when you move. If you prefer a softer, more feminine line from a relaxed coat, this is the one to try.
When the Cambridge Harris Tweed coat wins
Choose the Woman Cambridge Coat if warmth and a timeless wool look matter more than rain protection. The below-the-knee length adds coverage, and the raglan sleeves soften the shoulder line so the coat feels enveloping rather than structured.
Dark charcoal grey Harris Tweed is easy to wear with most winter palettes, and the fabric is the reason to buy it: textured, classic and described as made to last. If your winters are mostly cold and dry, or you already own a rain shell, the Cambridge is the more distinctive layer.
Sizing checkpoints before you order either coat
The two coats do not offer the same size run, so check availability against your usual size before deciding on fabric.
- Mac coat: S and M only: The Woman Oversized Mac Coat is listed in S and M. If you normally wear XS or L, the supplied catalog does not show a matching option.
- Cambridge coat: XS, S and M: The Cambridge is listed in XS, S and M. The raglan sleeve and below-knee cut mean the shoulder fit is less of a constraint, but the listed sizes are still the only ones confirmed.
- Oversized is a cut, not a size: The mac's oversized shape is intentional. If you want a closer fit, the tie belt does more work than sizing down, and sizing down is not something the catalog recommends.
What the catalog does not confirm
Neither record includes care instructions, lining information, exact garment measurements or a temperature rating. For the mac, the waxed cotton finish usually calls for specific care, but the supplied information does not state a method, so check the label or product page before cleaning. For the Cambridge, the Harris Tweed content is confirmed, but the lining and closure details are not.
That gap matters most if you need a coat for deep cold or heavy rain. The catalog supports the mac as water-resistant and the Cambridge as a wool tweed coat; it does not support claims about warmth ratings or waterproofing beyond those descriptions.
A simple way to decide
If wet weather and a belted, relaxed silhouette are your priorities, take the dark navy mac coat. If you want a below-the-knee wool layer with heritage texture and you can work within the XS–M size run, take the Cambridge Harris Tweed coat. Both are marked down from their comparison prices, so the decision is really about which fabric and shape you will reach for most often.



